In another great battle for the political ages, Fox News host Bill O’Reilly and the president of American Atheists David Silverman locked horns once again on Wednesday November 28, 2012 on the “Factor,” as the holiday sparks flew over the legitimacy of the Christmas holiday.
As many of you may know, Fox News trots out its favorite, annual Trojan horse known as the War on Christmas around this time, and this year is no different. Fox’s Bill O’Reilly is once again reeling in anger over the non-traditional, anti-Christmas antics of Rhode Island Governor Lincoln Chafee and his politically correct idea to label the official state tree a “holiday tree” instead of a “Christmas tree,” and this is what set the stage for O’Reilly and Silverman to have yet another corybantic clash.
O’Reilly came right out of the gate firing at Silverman asking him why he is so hell-bent on attacking the time honored tradition of Christmas. O’Reilly told Silverman that if he wanted to celebrate the Winter Solstice it was his American right to do so, like it is someone else’s right to celebrate Christmas.
Silverman countered with his argument by declaring that it was not anyone’s right to celebrate Christmas, because the government forces people to acknowledge and participate in Christmas on some level—either directly or indirectly, because it is a federal holiday. Silverman then irately complained to a stunned O’Reilly that he is unable to go to most stores, get his mail, or work on Christmas day, and that infringes on his rights, because he doesn’t have the power to force his employers to open for business on Christmas.
Now in O’Reilly’s defense, Silverman can’t force any merchant to do business on any day whether it’s Christmas or not. Just because a holiday is a federal holiday, it doesn’t mean that vendors have to shut down to recognize it, and there are many holidays that prove that. People like me have worked on many of them.
But the undisputed highlight of this entire exchange has to be one of the most bewildering statements ever made, as O’Reilly shocked the atheist world and probably most of the Christian and religious worlds too, by saying that “Christianity is not a religion,”
but merely “a philosophy.” In other words, Christianity is just another point of view—not necessarily the one and only true story of the one and only Son of God almighty.
A bemused Silverman looked at O’Reilly and told him that he could not believe what he just heard. And as the two men continued to disagree on whether or not Christianity is indeed a religion, an incensed O’Reilly took his bony, conservative finger and pointed right in the face of Silverman and called him a “fascist”—challenging him and his “merry band” of other “fascists” to start a move to get Christmas annulled as a federal holiday, and Silverman declined pointing towards a lack of support for it.
Now Christianity is not the basic, religious denomination like Methodism or Baptist, but it most certainly is a religion, and all religions and non-religions are philosophical. What stinks the most about O’Reilly’s ridiculous statement is the fact that if President Obama had said this, every right wing, Birther-loving, evangelical, born again, conservative, Bible thumping, Holy Rolling, Pat Robertson screwball would be up in their racist arms over it. President Obama would probably be impeached.
The political and religious fallout from O’Reilly’s boneheaded statement should be like a right wing avalanche bearing down on the weak, but it will probably be more like a journalistic trickle that has mistakenly slipped out of the Fox News faucet by mistake. Based on the religious magnitude of O’Reilly’s words, he should be moonwalking that statement back tonight, but don’t count on it!
Now personally, I’m not offended by the idea of Christmas, because I actually like the Christmas holiday. It doesn’t mean that I believe that Jesus is the Son of God, and it doesn’t mean that I believe that Jesus is a White man. It just means that I enjoy the incompetent, White man in a red suit who never gets me what I want.